Ebook · Build vs buy

Build or buy your load testing solution: what high-scale engineering teams should weigh

Where homegrown load testing gets expensive, what a platform has to handle at scale, how to compare total cost of ownership, and a 10-point checklist to decide if you should keep building.

See Gatling in action

Build, run, and interpret your first load test. A practical session: by the end, you'll know exactly what Enterprise gives you out of the box.

Loading next session...

30 minutes

Live + Q&A

Build vs buy

Why teams build, and why it's getting harder

Spinning up a single test is simple. Running a trustworthy, distributed, pipeline-driven performance platform that serves multiple teams is not. Many teams start with open source to validate behavior, then find that maintaining orchestration, analytics, integrations, and security turns into a hidden burden.

Users expect your application to feel as fast as the best in the world. That turns performance testing from a late-stage check into a continuous quality engine.

Microservices, edge, and hybrid cloud make realistic test scenarios distributed by design. And raw metrics aren't enough: teams need actionable insights, gated pipelines, and reliable governance. When evaluating options, most teams compare two paths.

Open source

Low cost, fast ramp, hands-on

Great for validating key flows and getting a first test into CI. You own everything around it.

Enterprise platform

Built for scale, insight, and team adoption

Orchestration, analysis, integrations, and governance are handled, so teams focus on the tests.

The risks and costs of building

The complexity shows up later

Teams usually build for control, flexibility, or cost. The deeper complexity tends to surface once more teams, regions, and pipelines depend on the platform.

01

Distributed orchestration

You coordinate generators across locations, retry logic, time sync, and result collection, and handle partial failures gracefully. That's ongoing engineering, not a one-off script.

02

Metrics firehose and analysis

High-cardinality time-series data has to be aggregated and retained so teams can compare runs and spot regressions quickly. Without that, people fall back to manual diffing and intuition.

03

Integration drift

CI vendors, runners, and APM tools keep changing. Keeping pipelines green means maintaining plugins, CLIs, and webhooks, and every broken connector costs confidence in testing.

04

Security and governance

SSO, RBAC, group-to-role mapping, quotas, auditing, and shareable reports are mandatory for cross-team adoption. Building and operating them well is not trivial.

05

Opportunity cost

Every hour spent keeping a homegrown platform alive is an hour not spent shipping product. Unless performance testing is your product, it's rarely the best use of your engineers.

The takeaway

DIY is great for exploring. At scale and over time, the operational surface area (distribution, analysis, integrations, and security) becomes the work.

01

Validate your approach first

Use open source or lighter tooling to validate key flows before investing in scale. Define your critical user journeys, test them in staging or dev, and check that your assertions make sense. Gatling supports JavaScript, TypeScript, Java, Scala, and Kotlin, and imports Postman collections to cover real flows faster. Start with a few key scenarios, simple assertions, and a first CI job.

Your stack is stretching when you need to
  • Run large and multi-region tests reliably
  • Compare runs and analyze regression trends without manual effort
  • Support different roles (dev, QA, SRE, management) from a shared platform
  • Automate tests in CI with stop criteria and gates
  • Enforce governance through SSO, RBAC, quotas, and safe result sharing
02

Scale your tests horizontally

Vertical scaling (one big host) hits limits quickly and can skew results. Distributed load generation lets you model global traffic patterns and regional failover, avoid single-host bottlenecks and noisy neighbors, and keep sensitive traffic in-network with private locations while still using a central UI and APIs for control and analysis.

Infrastructure as code
Define your load generators
  • Terraform, Helm, CloudFormation
Deployment environment
Your cloud or cluster
  • AWS, Azure, GCP, Kubernetes, on-prem
Load generators
Provisioned per run
  • Spawned on demand, removed after
System under test
Your application
  • Traffic stays in-network when needed

This is where "build" turns into "operate a product." A platform that already handles generator lifecycle, placement, and network constraints saves significant toil.

03

Embed performance into your delivery pipeline

Performance testing should protect releases, not slow them down. Run tests in CI on pull requests, merges, and on a schedule for long-running scenarios. Use stop criteria and performance gates to fail the pipeline when SLOs are breached, and compare runs to see exactly what changed between builds.

04

Collaborate across teams

Successful programs make performance a shared responsibility. Your solution has to work for every role involved.

Developers

Code-first authoring and fast feedback loops

QA and SRE

Dashboards, alerts, drill-downs, and trend analysis

Leads and managers

Shareable reports, project views, budgets, and quotas

Security and IT

SSO, RBAC, audit trails, and tenancy boundaries

If adoption requires manual workarounds or permission silos, performance testing becomes an afterthought instead of part of engineering culture.

05

Make it reliable, beyond "it runs"

At scale, a platform must deliver
  • Control-plane availability and auto-recovery when parts fail
  • Data aggregation and retention without runaway storage costs
  • Redundant capacity and regional flexibility, so tests still succeed when one path fails
  • Deployment choices (cloud, private, hybrid) that meet compliance, security, and data-sovereignty constraints

A mature platform ships these as table stakes. A homegrown stack has to evolve them deliberately.

Total cost of ownership

Don't compare "license vs. free"

Compare lifecycle costs and time to value. Once continuity, governance, and adoption are factored in, a managed platform often ends up cheaper and far less risky.

Engineering time

Building and maintaining orchestrators, data, dashboards, and plugins

Infrastructure

Compute, storage, egress, and capacity planning

Integration drift

CI, APM, and identity systems keep changing

On-call

Who gets paged when the test platform flakes?

Opportunity cost

Features and fixes your team didn't ship

Build vs. buy: pros and cons

DimensionBuildIn-house solutionBuyEnterprise platform
Time to valueFast to prototype or run a first POC, then slows sharply as you scale across teams or regions.Ready from day one, with faster onboarding and immediate value at scale.
Distributed orchestrationYou design and operate control, scheduling, retries, and data aggregation.Handled by the vendor, with consistent APIs and lifecycle management.
Metrics and analysisYou stand up a time-series database, retention, trends, and comparisons, and maintain them indefinitely.Built-in aggregation, trends, and run comparison to catch regressions quickly.
Automation and CI/CDYou maintain scripts and plugins as ecosystems evolve.Native plugins for any CI path, with stop criteria and gates to protect releases.
APM and alertsYou write and maintain an integration per tool.Documented, supported hooks and webhooks.
Security and governanceYou build SSO, RBAC, and quotas, and keep mappings and policies current.Enterprise SSO, RBAC, quotas, and audit built in.
Deploy anywhereCustom work to keep traffic in-network or on-prem with central control.Private locations run generators in your cloud or on-prem, with one-way control.
TCO and team focusLower upfront cost, rising operating cost and on-call, ongoing roadmap burden.License cost offset by less platform toil and a predictable evolution path.
Choose this whenYour requirements are highly unique, strategic, and tied to your product.Your needs are common and repeatable at scale, and extensible through APIs and integrations.
A practical checklist

Should we keep building?

Tick every statement that's true for your team today.

Build vs buy checklist
0 / 10

Tick the statements that are true for your team today.

It isn't black or white, and it isn't a forced path. You can keep using Gatling Community Edition locally to author tests (in JS, TS, Java, Scala, or Kotlin, or from a Postman import) while the platform handles scale, analysis, and governance.

Gatling Enterprise Edition

If load testing matters, your tool should too

Your users expect speed and reliability, and your load testing platform has to deliver the same. Gatling Enterprise Edition is built around five pillars.

Analyze smarter and act faster

Real-time visibility with dashboards, trend comparisons, and actionable insights.

Create tests your way

Code, low-code, or no-code: script in JavaScript, TypeScript, or Java, import Postman, or design visually.

Unlock automation

Trigger simulations from CI/CD or the API, apply stop criteria, and gate releases with performance thresholds.

Collaborate and share results

RBAC, SSO, quotas, and shared reports. Share results in Slack, Teams, or Jira.

Deploy load generators anywhere

Run tests from Gatling-managed regions, your own cloud, or on-prem.

Example Gatling test (JavaScript SDK)
import { constantUsersPerSec, scenario, simulation } from "@gatling.io/core"; import { http } from "@gatling.io/http"; export default simulation((setUp) => { // Define HTTP configuration const httpProtocol = http .baseUrl("https://api-ecomm.gatling.io") .acceptHeader("application/json"); // Define scenario const scn = scenario("Scenario").exec(http("Session").get("/session")); // Define injection profile and execute the test setUp(scn.injectOpen(constantUsersPerSec(2).during(60))) .protocols(httpProtocol); });
Ready to evaluate Enterprise Edition?

Keep the ebook, or see it in action

Take the full ebook to your next build vs. buy discussion, or see what you'd stop building yourself.

Download

Get the full ebook

The risks of building, the TCO comparison, and the 10-point checklist.

PDF · free, no form Download the PDF
Live session

See Gatling Enterprise Edition live

A guided walkthrough with a Gatling engineer, with time for your questions.

Join the next live session